号称自己是搞物流的人请进。

xiaoxin531

xiaoxin531

唐装墨玉

我同意xiaoxin531的看法。
SC存在，SCM我认为不存在，而存在 SCL（L=logistics），这点也是日本LILS协会的理念。
SCM只是一时间出现的时髦词语，从学术角度来看，为了达到独占，这危害消费者，从实际操作上来看，不现实，矛盾体过多，从我个人来看，也只不过是美国发明出来的一个咨询时髦用语，事实上只是为了普及IT，增大电脑使用率的。
至于技术，判断的工具越多越好。
另外，物流还是实战和现场，只不过我们国家现在多数在价格战，质量还远远没有达到市场竞争罢了，B2C不行就能看出来。规划以及IT等不能解决的东西，未免太多了。

easyhappy

这个有什么好讨论的，物流就是搬箱子，看你怎么搬好罢了。

log96

说供应链不存在只是因为你们站的高度不够高，我认为未来没有物流只有供应链

fc_ge

最初由 xiaoxin531 发布
[B]当然能看得懂. 只是觉得你的这些图片非但不能解释SCM 和LOGISTICS 两者的区别, 反而更容易让人混淆和糊涂,

个人的理解如下:
I think the logistics and supply chain management could overlap. Different companies define these two definations in their own ways. Generally speaking, the logistics is generally concerned with strategy and coordination of flows between marketing and production.  Such as  transportation and distribution.
So, I think that the Logistics is that part of the SCM process that plans, implements, and controls the efficient, effective forward and reverse flow and storage of goods, services, and related information between the point of origin and the point of consumption in order to meet customers' requirements.

就不知道你能不能看得懂了. [/B]

I can not read English. Specially, I can not read the English without logics. I challenge your comments in the flowing points:
First, "Logistis management is the part of SCM", I agree. But I do not agree on "Logistics is that part of SCM...."  They're deferent level.
Second, in the initial management theory, the four basic functions of management are planning, organizing, leading(implements), controlling. As you said,  The only thing between logistics management and SCM is organizing. It's absolutely wrong.
Third, I think the difference between LM and SCM is the scope. SCM is more wider than LM.
Thank you!
Frankly speaking, I don't like you speaking style!

youngvc

真不知道大侠是干什么的！！！请您赐教阿

log96

在物流这个圈子里面混，啥都干过

丰羽

最初由 xiaoxin531 发布
[B]楼上的那位叫什么丰羽的朋友, 马屁和风凉话说的还真及时.
有本事的来说说你的"高论". 少在这里假大空. [/B]

高论不敢有啊！
咱只能给老板打打工，降低一些不必要的成本，提高一下客户需要的服务水平而已！顺便跟老板要些工资糊口！当然，老板因为客户高兴，还会给点奖金期权之类的．跟您那是不能比．肚里有货啊！装了一肚子洋墨水！

log96

我们欢迎不同的声音，希望听到不同的看法，如果只有一个声音那这个世界是多么的单调